Home / AUDI / S5

Audi S5 Problems

The Audi S5 is a high-performance luxury coupe, convertible, and sportback produced since 2007, offering a step up from the A5 with more powerful engines and sport-tuned suspension. With 380 complaints recorded, issues concentrated in the 2020 model year. The S5 provides engaging performance with Quattro all-wheel drive and various V6 and V8 engines over its generations. The current turbocharged V6 produces 349 horsepower and delivers effortless acceleration.

380
Total Complaints
22
Total Recalls
16
Model Years
0
Reported Deaths
!

Years to Avoid

These years have significantly more complaints than average.

2020 2018
✓

Best Years

These years have the fewest reported problems.

2008 2015 2016

Common Problem Categories

Unknown Or Other 52
Power Train 50
Air Bags 50
Engine 42
Electrical System 42

Complaints by Model Year

All Model Years

Year ↓ Complaints Recalls Crashes Fires Rating
2025 16 2 0 0 Average
2024 4 0 0 0 Good
2023 6 1 2 0 Good
2022 4 2 0 0 Good
2021 2 5 0 0 Good
2020 100 4 0 0 Avoid
2019 8 4 0 0 Good
2018 80 2 8 0 Avoid
2016 6 0 0 0 Good
2015 8 0 0 0 Good
2014 14 0 0 0 Average
2013 36 0 0 0 Below Average
2012 20 1 0 0 Average
2011 18 1 0 0 Average
2010 52 0 0 0 Below Average
2008 6 0 0 0 Good

Audi S5 Years to Avoid

The 2020 S5 accumulated the most complaints with infotainment system malfunctions, virtual cockpit glitches, and various electronic issues. The 2008-2009 first-generation V8 models had some timing chain and carbon buildup concerns. The 2018 also showed elevated complaint levels during its first-year redesign.

Best Audi S5 Years

The 2021-2023 S5 models benefited from resolved 2020 issues and represent well-sorted examples. The 2014-2016 supercharged V6 models offer proven performance with good reliability. The 2015 S5 represents excellent value with the thrilling supercharged soundtrack.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the S5 reliable?

Moderately reliable for a German performance car. The supercharged 3.0T (2010-2017) and turbocharged 3.0T (2018+) are proven engines. Electronics cause most complaints. Budget $2,000-3,000 annually for maintenance.

What's the difference between A5 and S5?

The S5 has more power (349 hp vs 261 hp currently), sport suspension, larger brakes, Quattro standard, and sportier styling cues. It costs about $10,000 more. The performance difference is significant.

What are common S5 problems?

First generation: carbon buildup, timing chain concerns on V8. Second generation (2010-2017): relatively few issues. Third generation (2018+): infotainment glitches, virtual cockpit freezes. All need regular service.

Is the S5 better than the BMW 440i?

Both are competitive. The S5 has Quattro standard and slightly better interior quality. The BMW offers rear-drive purity (though xDrive is available) and sharper handling. It's a draw based on priorities.

Should I buy the S5 coupe or sportback?

The sportback offers more practicality with four doors and a larger hatch opening. The coupe has purer styling. Performance is identical. Sportback depreciation may be slower due to practicality appeal.