Home / BMW / M5

Bmw M5 Problems

The BMW M5 is BMW's high-performance variant of the 5 Series sedan, offering supercar performance in a practical package. With 290 complaints and 4 deaths on record, the M5 delivers extraordinary power but requires knowledgeable ownership and expensive maintenance. Each generation has defined the super sedan category, though reliability has varied significantly across generations.

290
Total Complaints
29
Total Recalls
19
Model Years
4
Reported Deaths
!

Years to Avoid

These years have significantly more complaints than average.

2006
✓

Best Years

These years have the fewest reported problems.

2003 2010 2016

Common Problem Categories

Air Bags 92
Engine 42
Power Train 26
Seat Belts 20
Electrical System 18

Complaints by Model Year

All Model Years

Year ↓ Complaints Recalls Crashes Fires Rating
2025 4 1 0 0 Good
2022 2 0 0 0 Good
2021 8 1 0 6 Average
2020 2 3 0 0 Good
2019 18 3 0 0 Average
2018 14 3 0 0 Average
2016 2 2 0 0 Good
2015 8 1 0 0 Average
2014 8 1 0 0 Average
2013 32 2 0 4 Below Average
2010 6 2 0 0 Good
2009 0 2 0 0 Good
2008 24 2 4 6 Below Average
2007 16 1 0 0 Average
2006 108 1 6 0 Avoid
2003 6 1 0 0 Good
2002 14 2 0 0 Average
2001 8 1 0 0 Average
2000 10 0 4 4 Average

Bmw M5 Years to Avoid

The 2006 M5 (E60) had the most complaints, featuring the high-revving S85 V10 engine that is mechanically complex and expensive to maintain. Rod bearing failures, throttle actuator issues, and SMG transmission problems are well-documented. Ownership costs can be staggering.

Best Bmw M5 Years

The 2020 M5 (F90) represents a more mature, daily-drivable M5 with the twin-turbo V8 offering massive power and improved reliability. The F90 generation has fewer reported issues and better long-term prospects.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the E60 M5 V10 reliable?

No. The S85 V10 has known rod bearing issues that can cause catastrophic failure. Throttle actuators fail, and the SMG transmission is expensive to repair. Budget ,000-10,000 annually minimum.

Should I buy a cheap E60 M5?

Only if you have deep pockets and mechanical understanding. A ,000 E60 M5 can easily cost ,000 in repairs. The low purchase price reflects the high risk.

Which M5 generation is most reliable?

The E39 M5 (1999-2003) with the S62 V8 is the most reliable and has become collectible. The F10 and F90 generations are reasonable with maintenance. Avoid E60 V10 models.

How much does M5 maintenance cost?

Budget ,000-15,000 annually depending on generation. The E60 V10 is most expensive. Tires, brakes, and fluids alone cost significantly more than regular 5 Series.

Is the M5 worth the money?

For enthusiasts who understand the costs, the M5 offers unmatched performance in a sedan. For everyone else, the M550i offers 80 percent of the performance with far lower costs.