This Problem Across All Years
• Third-row seat in my 2020 BMW X7 failed during normal operation and trapped my [XXX] daughter between the seatbacks. • She sustained injuries to her legs (documented in photos). I injured my arm while trying to free her. • Approximately 10 people witnessed the incident. • Seat would not move or release electronically or manually—no functional emergency release. • Multiple BMW system warnings occurred before the incident, including: – “Third row seat risk of injury” – “Right/left rear seat unlocked” – “Right/left rear seat back unlocked” • BMW’s inspection found the passenger-side third-row seat motor housing broken. • There was no misuse and the failure occurred during normal operation • BMW refuses to repair the defect under warranty and attempted to return the vehicle unrepaired. • BMW suggested an “outside influence,” but evidence does not support this. • This defect creates a serious entrapment and injury hazard with no reliable manual release. • Requesting NHTSA investigation into BMW X7 third-row seat motors, locking mechanisms, and lack of emergency release due to risk of occupant injury or inability to evacuate a trapped passenger. There is an open and unresolved case with the manufacturer. Please help us and others that may be in danger. We still don’t have our vehicle back after 6 weeks and they state they will not fix it and return it to us broken, unsafe, and not usable. Here is the contact at BMW Gabrielle Dorcean Executive Customer Care, Customer Relations and Services BMW of North America, LLC Phone: [XXX] [XXX] Email: [email protected] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
• Third-row seat in my 2020 BMW X7 failed during normal operation and trapped my [XXX] daughter between the seatbacks. • She sustained injuries to her legs (documented in photos). I injured my arm while trying to free her. • Approximately 10 people witnessed the incident. • Seat would not move or release electronically or manually—no functional emergency release. • Multiple BMW system warnings occurred before the incident, including: – “Third row seat risk of injury” – “Right/left rear seat unlocked” – “Right/left rear seat back unlocked” • BMW’s inspection found the passenger-side third-row seat motor housing broken. • There was no misuse and the failure occurred during normal operation • BMW refuses to repair the defect under warranty and attempted to return the vehicle unrepaired. • BMW suggested an “outside influence,” but evidence does not support this. • This defect creates a serious entrapment and injury hazard with no reliable manual release. • Requesting NHTSA investigation into BMW X7 third-row seat motors, locking mechanisms, and lack of emergency release due to risk of occupant injury or inability to evacuate a trapped passenger. There is an open and unresolved case with the manufacturer. Please help us and others that may be in danger. We still don’t have our vehicle back after 6 weeks and they state they will not fix it and return it to us broken, unsafe, and not usable. Here is the contact at BMW Gabrielle Dorcean Executive Customer Care, Customer Relations and Services BMW of North America, LLC Phone: [XXX] [XXX] Email: [email protected] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
• Third-row seat in my 2020 BMW X7 failed during normal operation and trapped my [XXX] daughter between the seatbacks. • She sustained injuries to her legs (documented in photos). I injured my arm while trying to free her. • Approximately 10 people witnessed the incident. • Seat would not move or release electronically or manually—no functional emergency release. • Multiple BMW system warnings occurred before the incident, including: – “Third row seat risk of injury” – “Right/left rear seat unlocked” – “Right/left rear seat back unlocked” • BMW’s inspection found the passenger-side third-row seat motor housing broken. • There was no misuse and the failure occurred during normal operation • BMW refuses to repair the defect under warranty and attempted to return the vehicle unrepaired. • BMW suggested an “outside influence,” but evidence does not support this. • This defect creates a serious entrapment and injury hazard with no reliable manual release. • Requesting NHTSA investigation into BMW X7 third-row seat motors, locking mechanisms, and lack of emergency release due to risk of occupant injury or inability to evacuate a trapped passenger. There is an open and unresolved case with the manufacturer. Please help us and others that may be in danger. We still don’t have our vehicle back after 6 weeks and they state they will not fix it and return it to us broken, unsafe, and not usable. Here is the contact at BMW Gabrielle Dorcean Executive Customer Care, Customer Relations and Services BMW of North America, LLC Phone: [XXX] [XXX] Email: [email protected] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
• Third-row seat in my 2020 BMW X7 failed during normal operation and trapped my [XXX] daughter between the seatbacks. • She sustained injuries to her legs (documented in photos). I injured my arm while trying to free her. • Approximately 10 people witnessed the incident. • Seat would not move or release electronically or manually—no functional emergency release. • Multiple BMW system warnings occurred before the incident, including: – “Third row seat risk of injury” – “Right/left rear seat unlocked” – “Right/left rear seat back unlocked” • BMW’s inspection found the passenger-side third-row seat motor housing broken. • There was no misuse and the failure occurred during normal operation • BMW refuses to repair the defect under warranty and attempted to return the vehicle unrepaired. • BMW suggested an “outside influence,” but evidence does not support this. • This defect creates a serious entrapment and injury hazard with no reliable manual release. • Requesting NHTSA investigation into BMW X7 third-row seat motors, locking mechanisms, and lack of emergency release due to risk of occupant injury or inability to evacuate a trapped passenger. There is an open and unresolved case with the manufacturer. Please help us and others that may be in danger. We still don’t have our vehicle back after 6 weeks and they state they will not fix it and return it to us broken, unsafe, and not usable. Here is the contact at BMW Gabrielle Dorcean Executive Customer Care, Customer Relations and Services BMW of North America, LLC Phone: [XXX] [XXX] Email: [email protected] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
I am filing this complaint because the third-row passenger seat in my 2020 BMW X7 has a serious defect that poses an immediate safety risk to children and passengers. The third-row seat malfunctioned while my child was exiting the vehicle. The powered seat began moving unexpectedly and trapped my child’s leg, and we had extreme difficulty getting the seat to release. This is an extremely dangerous failure for any powered seat, especially one that is frequently used by children. This is not normal wear and tear — this is a mechanical and electrical failure of a safety-critical seat system. BMW Fresno has had the vehicle for more than six weeks and cannot fix the problem. BMW North America reviewed the case but denied responsibility and closed it, even though the defect affects a powered safety-critical seat. We still have no repair, no explanation, and no assurance that the seat is safe. I am filing this because the powered seat poses a clear risk of injury, and BMW has not resolved or acknowledged the safety defect. I request that NHTSA investigate the 2020 BMW X7 third-row seat system for potential entrapment hazards. Actions Taken •BMW Fresno inspected the vehicle and kept it for 6+ weeks. •BMW NA conducted a review but has refused to cover cost of repair or acknowledge a defect. •I am seeking NHTSA’s involvement because this is a clear safety problem that BMW has not corrected.
I am filing this complaint because the third-row passenger seat in my 2020 BMW X7 has a serious defect that poses an immediate safety risk to children and passengers. The third-row seat malfunctioned while my child was exiting the vehicle. The powered seat began moving unexpectedly and trapped my child’s leg, and we had extreme difficulty getting the seat to release. This is an extremely dangerous failure for any powered seat, especially one that is frequently used by children. This is not normal wear and tear — this is a mechanical and electrical failure of a safety-critical seat system. BMW Fresno has had the vehicle for more than six weeks and cannot fix the problem. BMW North America reviewed the case but denied responsibility and closed it, even though the defect affects a powered safety-critical seat. We still have no repair, no explanation, and no assurance that the seat is safe. I am filing this because the powered seat poses a clear risk of injury, and BMW has not resolved or acknowledged the safety defect. I request that NHTSA investigate the 2020 BMW X7 third-row seat system for potential entrapment hazards. Actions Taken •BMW Fresno inspected the vehicle and kept it for 6+ weeks. •BMW NA conducted a review but has refused to cover cost of repair or acknowledge a defect. •I am seeking NHTSA’s involvement because this is a clear safety problem that BMW has not corrected.
I am submitting this complaint based on recurring drivetrain and structural failures in my 2020 BMW X7 (VIN: [XXX] ), which raise serious concerns about reliability and safety. Most recently, the vehicle exhibited shuddering, power loss, and a “neutral-like” disengagement at low speeds. BMW of Pembroke Pines confirmed this through a test drive. However, instead of mechanical replacement, the dealer performed a VTG oil flush and attempted a calibration, which—according to their own documentation—“lost connection.” These signs point to recurring issues with the ATC (transfer case), a known point of failure in several BMW X models. Additional manufacturer defects I’ve experienced include: - Two incidents of cabin water intrusion from separate leaks - A dashboard panel burst shortly after purchase - Rear seat failure requiring a $7,000+ repair BMW North America refuses to provide further assistance despite acknowledging the repair history. This leaves me with a potentially unsafe vehicle, prone to recurring drivetrain failure without a clearly defined remedy. I respectfully request that NHTSA investigate whether the Active Transfer Case and related VTG components in the BMW X7 pose a defect trend requiring formal attention. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
I am submitting this complaint based on recurring drivetrain and structural failures in my 2020 BMW X7 (VIN: [XXX] ), which raise serious concerns about reliability and safety. Most recently, the vehicle exhibited shuddering, power loss, and a “neutral-like” disengagement at low speeds. BMW of Pembroke Pines confirmed this through a test drive. However, instead of mechanical replacement, the dealer performed a VTG oil flush and attempted a calibration, which—according to their own documentation—“lost connection.” These signs point to recurring issues with the ATC (transfer case), a known point of failure in several BMW X models. Additional manufacturer defects I’ve experienced include: - Two incidents of cabin water intrusion from separate leaks - A dashboard panel burst shortly after purchase - Rear seat failure requiring a $7,000+ repair BMW North America refuses to provide further assistance despite acknowledging the repair history. This leaves me with a potentially unsafe vehicle, prone to recurring drivetrain failure without a clearly defined remedy. I respectfully request that NHTSA investigate whether the Active Transfer Case and related VTG components in the BMW X7 pose a defect trend requiring formal attention. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
Third row seat malfunction sending rear seat back unlocked appearing on dash. Switch for third row seat is faulty and need to be replaced. Warning states a safety issue with seat being unlocked. Inspected by bmw passport. The notice came up 3 days ago on dash vehicle was purchased from global auto outlet 12/26/24
Third row seat malfunction sending rear seat back unlocked appearing on dash. Switch for third row seat is faulty and need to be replaced. Warning states a safety issue with seat being unlocked. Inspected by bmw passport. The notice came up 3 days ago on dash vehicle was purchased from global auto outlet 12/26/24
The failed component was observed when the Restraint warning icon appeared. There was no accident because the vehicle was taken to the BMW dealership for investigation. There is a warning not to drive because the Restraint system may not work properly. This is a safety issue with no work around to operate the vehicle in a safe manner. After reviewing multiple threads online, it appears that my situation is not uncommon with BMW. I took the vehicle to BMW service and they confirmed there is a fault in the harness that allows the airbag, seat belt and tensioner to not operate properly in the case of a collision. The service advisor admitted they have seen this before and knew how to repair it. The repair is too costly to investigate the harness where the defect in the wiring occurred, so the opt to replace the harness in a parallel manner, which still takes 7 hours and over $2200. The vehicle is only a few months out of warranty and has less than 18,000 total miles. They is no way that the harness experienced normal wear over the years to cause this with such low miles. They attempted to blame the Arizona heat as possible cause, but the vehicle was in Illinois to 2 of the 4 years and while in Arizona, it is parked in my air conditioned garage. Heat is not the cause. This situation is a design defect during assembly or a defective harness at manufacturer. BMW would not accept any responsibility for the issue, which is a safety liability to passengers.
The failed component was observed when the Restraint warning icon appeared. There was no accident because the vehicle was taken to the BMW dealership for investigation. There is a warning not to drive because the Restraint system may not work properly. This is a safety issue with no work around to operate the vehicle in a safe manner. After reviewing multiple threads online, it appears that my situation is not uncommon with BMW. I took the vehicle to BMW service and they confirmed there is a fault in the harness that allows the airbag, seat belt and tensioner to not operate properly in the case of a collision. The service advisor admitted they have seen this before and knew how to repair it. The repair is too costly to investigate the harness where the defect in the wiring occurred, so the opt to replace the harness in a parallel manner, which still takes 7 hours and over $2200. The vehicle is only a few months out of warranty and has less than 18,000 total miles. They is no way that the harness experienced normal wear over the years to cause this with such low miles. They attempted to blame the Arizona heat as possible cause, but the vehicle was in Illinois to 2 of the 4 years and while in Arizona, it is parked in my air conditioned garage. Heat is not the cause. This situation is a design defect during assembly or a defective harness at manufacturer. BMW would not accept any responsibility for the issue, which is a safety liability to passengers.